To kick things off, we'll start with a classic entry: "Jeff the Killer." What this story lacks in nuance, it makes up for in middle school fright value. "Jeff the Killer" is a real delight for droves of high schoolers, but the chilling image that comes along with it is enough to give a reader of any age a fright. He is an adolescent serial killer and registered Creepypasta.  He was disfigured after being set on fire while fighting a gang of bullies and lost his sanity after witnessing his "new"   and "beautiful" face.